I once had a player that wanted a Decanter of Endless Water just to waterboard people 😳
I think the screams would be muffled but still audible. Until the bag is closed, the extradimensional space inside is connected to the outside world. However, since sound can only escape from the opening and not the sides of the bag, I would rule that it is much quieter, granting disadvantage on checks to hear the scream.
This is an eminently reasonable ruling and I’s appreciates yous
It’s up to the DM if it comes across like a portal to enter the bag or an impossible space like the TARDIS. Air does not flow between as you can suffocate and air would carry the sound, but I always rule it as feeling more like in impossibly large space rather than a magical portal.
Idk, that feels a bit too technical. Trying to apply real world physics to D&D breaks way more things than just this, so we gotta be careful when to do it. Gotta keep just enough believability and consistency, without letting it ruin the feel.
For me, the fact that “starwars lasers go pew pew” is enough reason to disregard how sound actually works in real life, lol.
To be fair I’d just rule in favour of the players the first time it comes up. If they want it as a silencer with the prerequisite of putting it over someone’s head, that’s cool because the enemy will struggle and make it difficult.
If it’s debut was from an enemy doing it to a PC who said they’d yell extra hard to call for help, I’d probably ask for a skill check and say the sound does pass through.
From then on, I’d just keep that ruling.
I always interpreted the suffocation to be only while the bag is closed. It doesn’t make much sense if physical objects can enter the bag but not air. Why not?
Creating the bag would create a very big underpressure, immediately imploding the bag and probably killing the creator
Well maybe the extradimensional space comes with air. But I never thought about that before haha.
It’s linked to the astral sea, somehow, so it probably comes with some amount of astral sea at approximately astral sea levels of pressure.
The bag holds a certain amount of air, per the description’s time. I was surprised at how close the math was- it’s a fair approximation of an average person within a sealed 1 atmosphere room of identical size.
You could just kill the guard by leaving them in the bag
I would immediately shift your alignment to chaotic evil for it because you’re literally making them suffocate to death over a period of about ten minutes, but it’s still RAW.
Except if the guard manages to rip a hole in the bag from the inside, they can destroy the bag and everything inside it will get scattered across the Astral Plane. Pretty bad for the guard, but better than a slow death being suffocated. Plus you don’t need to eat or breathe on the Astral, so they could live there indefinitely.
Tearing the bag from the inside seems like an easier said than done proposition.
Not if they have a blade. Sticking anything sharp inside the bag tears it.
Also, I would much rather suffocate over 10 minutes(which would suck horribly) than live out the rest of my natural life floating alone in the astral plane.
And that’s only if they recognize what’s going on. If you’re just minding your business and suddenly it’s dark and hard to breathe, there are a bunch of monsters, spells, and magical phenomena that are possible culprits.
I’m still going to wildly swing my scimitar in the dark
Do things inside float? Wouldn’t that make them unreachable if they float away from the opening?
Would a person die in a bag of holding or is it like the Astral plane and bodily needs are paused?
Yes. It’s specifies there’s ten minutes of air. But the bag woodt need to be closed to not have air exchange.
You’re right, and the rules (both 3.5 and 5) even explicitly state that after ten minutes the creature suffocates. I was hoping that the RAW was simply “holds enough air for a Medium creature to breathe for ten minutes” which I could try to argue was merely a statement about the inner volume of the bag.
I’ve always imagined a bag of holding to be like some kind of stasis.
Bag of holding around the head. Tear it.
Faster in theory but I’d be incredibly tempted to have it create an astral plane flavored headless horseman enemy
Bodyless floater in this case, as the body is on the Prime Material plane.
Oh damn that’s good
This sort of thing always seem silly to me. Most of the people you kill go to the lower planes. What is ten minutes of suffocation compared to that?
Bro if you don’t get how painful suffocation can be just sympathetically I’m not sure I can explain why doing that to someone on purpose is so heinous
I get that it can be painful. it just seems like it would be less painful than an eternity on the lower planes. And I wouldn’t want to play a character that does that sort of thing, but that basically means I can’t play D&D without homebrewing a less dark cosmology. If you are playing it with the cosmology they give you, and you’re not careful to keep your enemies alive, then you’re doing stuff worse than this constantly.
If it “holds” the screams as if it was an item, would you be able to pull a scream out of the bag at will? Does than then mean that you can use the bag to prepare verbal components of spells?
Anything you can do, the DM can do, too. Treat things like this like war crimes or your next TPK will be a goblin horde taking out the party one by one with sneak attacks and bags of holding.
If you think that you are the players enemy instead of guide maybe.
I understand that it’s not a competition or a win/lose kind of game. Personally, I use TRRPGs as story engines for my make-believe characters, but if my players decide to throw jank at me, I have permission to throw jank at them.
That seems like a good idea for parties that constantly exploit everything they can. One off creativity should probably be rewarded though.
Honestly if you wanna give your party a bag of holding, sticking it on a bugbear assassin who uses this tactic and then uses the bag to dispose of bodies is a fun way to introduce it.
Anything the players do, I be DM can do too, yt if it uses a niche magic item, the DM better be prepared for it to end up in the hands of the players.
So true, and your players will cherish it for the sentiment of the victory.
It would silence as many screams as hands you are loosing pulling items from it. Which is zero.
I would say yes, it’s a poket dimension with no air so the sound would have no medium to flow through. Thank you for coming to my Ted talk
Seriously, super fun info for later!
It has enough air for one creature to breath for 10 minutes. And since the bag isn’t closed when it’s on the victim’s head there is a connection between the pocket dimension and the material world through which sound waves may travel.
I do believe you are correct, thank you for correcting me good sir
This is funny, I see your point but would rule the opposite. Because the bag wouldn’t be able to close due to a neck being in the way it wouldn’t seal the pocket dimension and I would rule the guard would still be able to breath (and scream) through the bag.
I do believe you are correct, thank you for correcting me good sir
This is why you chop them into bag sized pieces first
If there’s no air, wouldn’t it ruin a bunch of stuff you put in? Any liquids would evaporate, wood could deteriorate, etc. Is it also cold? That also causes changes to a bunch of stuff.
The Dungeons and Daddies guys took out a CR26 Vampire Lord at Level 2 with this one neat trick…
Put the bag of holding over his head and let the Bagman have him
When you put his head in the bag you are also putting the air around his head in the bag so any “sound doesn’t travel in a vacuum” arguments will be nonsense.
I imagine it would be just as loud as if someone poked their head out of a porthole of a ship and yelled outside. Someone inside the room of the ship could still hear it even though the victims head is poking through the porthole.
I thought it wouldn’t make sense at first, but thinking about it more I think it does. Sound can’t travel through the walls of the bug. It probably echos inside it, but there’s not a lot of air around their neck for it to come out through, and sound doesn’t travel well between gases and solids, so most of the sound would be absorbed. It wouldn’t be perfect, but it would make it a lot quieter.
Polymorph them into a caterpillar and toss them into the bag. Easy and silent murder.
deleted by creator
Couldn’t you just close the draw string and decapitate the target?
EDIT: Or make the drawstring out of piano wire to ensure the result.
Is your bags drawstring made out of friggin piano wire?
Even if it were, it still has bag cloth surrounding it.
