If you don’t earn over a million dollars a year then it’s obvious that Biden is the right choice
The guy who broke the strike of an absurdly profitable rail company?
I mean it’s a choice between open contempt for the workers, and open contempt, but occasionally putting on a union hat for a photo op before either doing nothing or siding with management.
If you actually look at the details of the story you’re taking about you’ll find that after Biden ordered them back to work he then ALSO got the train companies to give the workers everything the union had been asking for
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2022_United_States_railroad_labor_dispute
Thanks for posting and explaining some of this. I also had the mistaken impression that he just had forced them all back to work. It never sat right with me. I wasn’t aware that a lot of things happened after that.
In September 2022, U.S. Senators Richard Burr and Roger Wicker introduced a bill that would have required labor unions to agree to the terms proposed by the Presidential Emergency Board, to prevent a strike.[18] It was blocked by Senator Bernie Sanders, who noted that freight rail workers receive a “grand total of zero sick days” while railroad companies made significant profits.[19] In the House of Representatives, Speaker Nancy Pelosi said, “We’d rather see negotiations prevail so there’s no need for any actions from Congress.”[16]
In late November, after some unions had rejected the agreement, Biden asked Congress to pass the agreement into law. On November 30, the House of Representatives passed the existing tentative agreement along with an amended version that would require railroad employers to ensure 7 days paid sick leave.[20] On December 1, the Senate passed the tentative agreement with only 1 day of sick leave.[21] President Joe Biden signed the legislation into law on December 2.[4] Writing for Jacobin, Barry Eidlin, associate professor of sociology at McGill University, said the message sent to the rail workers by the president and Congress was “shut up and get back to work.”[22] The Biden administration’s intervention in the dispute was condemned by over 500 labor historians in an open letter to Joe Biden and Secretary of Labor Marty Walsh.[23]
Sounds like Bernie went to bat for them, and then Biden forced a compromise the industry wanted but most unions disagreed with…
I mean, Biden got them a single sick day when they were only asking for 7 days.
That’s not a great win for unions, that’s a middle finger.
It’s literally the smallest amount of sick days they could have so they could stop saying “we do t get sick days”.
And a cynic would say the only reason they got the one is “we don’t have enough sick days” doesn’t Garner as much sympathy in a headline.
But I’m just going off what you linked, do you want to try and find one that does back up your version of events?
The unions wanted 15 sick days, Biden forced them to accept the company’s offer of 1 day unpaid sickleave. Later it was increased to 7, plus a wage increase of 14%+4.5% per year for 5 years. That doesn’t even keep up with inflation.
Biden could have simply ordered the railroad to accept the union’s demands, hell he could have nationalized the rail companies in question, but his job is to represent capital, not labor.
To put into perspective how much of a pittance this is, BNSF is so profitable, they could afford to give every worker a raise of 100,000 and still afford to give Warren Buffet a billion dollars every year. This is the equivalent of Trump giving the .1% billions in tax breaks and telling workers they should support him because they get an extra 12 bucks in their tax returns.
Dude you just moved the goalposts a million lightyears away from what you said in your original comment.
Secondly, YOU don’t get to decide what the rail union’s opinion on the matter is, only the rail union can speak for the rail union, and they’ve all publicly said how very happy they are with the outcome of Biden’s actions
https://www.theguardian.com/business/2023/may/01/railroad-workers-union-win-sick-leave
I cannot conceive of how the leadership could both represent their workers and be happy Biden sided with the board, against the workers.
Because that’s not what happened.
He literally required them to accept the board’s offer. The company offering minor concessions afterword doesn’t change the fact that he sided against the workers.
Biden could have simply ordered the railroad to accept the union’s demands
Ah yes, the “president has a magic wand” theory of governance.
It is, in fact, not quite as simple as I’m trying to make it sound, and there are some things to complain about in what Biden did. Here’s a pretty good summary of the “Biden did wrong” thesis.
My take on it is that Biden launched legislation to grant them 7 days of sick leave by law. It passed the house on a party-line vote, and then failed in the senate by 8 votes. When the senate passed an amended version that would grant 1 day of sick leave, what would you want Biden to do? Assuming he doesn’t have the ability to just ignore the law and order the rail companies to give the benefits he thinks they should be giving, because we don’t have a command economy under the total authority of one person?
Here’s a partial summary of what Biden’s labor department had done by working the issue after the fuss had died down in the rest of government. It’s complicated by the fact that there are multiple companies and multiple unions all with separate agreements, but my overall take is that it looks like he’s been trying to balance securing justice for the workers, with what he can get the rest of government to cooperate with, with keeping the economy running and not grinding to a halt.
Honestly, the point of view that he should have let the economy grind to a halt if that’s what the people who actually do the work want to have happen, in order to secure some economic justice for themselves, I can understand that. It makes sense to me. Honestly, that is more or less my personal point of view on it. But I think calling him a shockingly anti-union US president because he won’t do that is overstating how pro-union people in US politics tend to be.
There were 458,900 workers involved in work stoppages in 2023, notably including the even-more-unprecedented-than-the-rail-strike motion picture strike and the autoworkers strike. You can believe, if you want to, that Biden is anti-union and he just overlooked his responsibility to shut down the 458,900 people who did work stoppages in 2023. Personally my feeling is that he shut down the rail strike because it would have a big impact on the rest of the economy, then his labor department kept working the issue and got the workers the sick days they were fighting for in the first place by having the strike.
Is your assertion here that United Steelworkers just fucked up and endorsed a rabidly anti-union candidate because they’re not as up to speed on labor issues as you are?
Is your assertion here that United Steelworkers just fucked up and endorsed a rabidly anti-union candidate because they’re not as up to speed on labor issues as you are?
I really appreciate the “you really think you’re smarter than the people whose job it is to do this?” Energy being exuded here. Spot on.
I had no idea he negotiated to get them the things they wanted afterwards, thank you for sharing that. I was completely unaware
What the fuck is going on in the comments here?
It’s even worse here.
Literally the topic of the OP article is “If you look at what the economic situation is for workers in the US, it’s almost as good as it was pre-Covid which is a goddamned miracle. It’s not perfect, still a lot of people are struggling, but $15/hr being the new more-or-less entry level minimum wage and some increased union membership has produced real progress especially at the bottom end of the scale, when a lot of first-world economies are still struggling to dig themselves out even back to normal. Wage inequality is down, unemployment is the lowest it’s been in decades, etc etc, Biden deserves some credit for that. Here are detailed citations to back all that up. It’s weird that that’s not the popular perception.”
Then, go look at the comments and read them through. It’s literally a nonstop tide of rando user accounts saying “but inflation stacks year on year, they don’t know basic math” and “they just think stocks going up means the economy’s better, they don’t care people are hurting” and “my grocery bill is high things are real bad, I’m suffering, this article’s not true.” It’s almost impossible to read the comments front to back and hold on in your head to the fact that they’re objectively wrong. It’s like Goebbels’s propaganda theory in real time – if you grab out one individual comment and analyze it and really think about it, compare it to evidence, it falls apart. But looking at them all together it really looks like there’s this groundswell of opinion. It also makes it more or less impossible to actually have a conversation about the article because it gets swarmed with people talking discouraging nonsense and being apparently incapable of absorbing anything different.
holy smokes ur right, it’s so bad (or maybe im so weak willed) that i genuinely can’t tell if you are the one full of b.s. or not (no offense to you im just trippin out over this)
I am biased, because I think I’m right and they are wrong, but to me it is instructive to look at an example like this
It removes it from that flood-of-unopposed-propaganda world and puts it into a more manageable context, like here are questions, and here’s how people answer the questions or not.
thanks, i do see what you are saying
after much lip biting and teeth grinding i posted a comment which represents my position which i hope isn’t too enlightened centrist. you at least seem good faith so i’d appreciate your opinion lol
Organized election trolling starting to consider Lemmy?
Organized election trolling starting to consider Lemmy
?FTFY
Organized election trolling
starting toconsider Lemmy?
i am afraid
This is the best summary I could come up with:
The 1.2 million-member union, which also backed Biden in 2020 over Trump, represents workers in auto supply, glass, rubber, chemicals, pulp and paper, mining and other industries.
Union President David McCall said Biden’s leadership allowed workers to carve out more room for bargaining and better support for the middle class.
“His vision and leadership allowed our nation to strengthen workers’ access to collective bargaining, grow the middle class, and embark on a path to widespread prosperity.”
Biden has touted himself as the “most pro-union president in American history” and gotten backing from various labor unions, including the United Auto Workers, SEIU and the AFL-CIO.
McCall added that Trump has not reached out to him and the former president’s campaign didn’t even respond to its issues survey they sent out to all prospective presidential candidates in both parties.
The union’s leaders met with Biden last week while also previously meeting with third-party candidates Robert F. Kennedy Jr. and Cornel West.
The original article contains 309 words, the summary contains 159 words. Saved 49%. I’m a bot and I’m open source!
FLOYD FLOYD SEETHE CHUCK’S AND GUCCI LOAFERS JANNY HOT POCKETS GUCCI LOAFERS FANCY GERMAN CAR I CAN’T HOT POCKETS DILATE CITY SLICKER CHUCK’S CITY SLICKER ON LEMMY CLEAN IT UP COPE SNEED SEETHE CLEAN IT UP CITY SLICKER COPE JANNIES JANNIES CHUCK’S FANCY GERMAN CAR I CAN’T PARK AVENUE MANICURE FLOYD SUCK CHUCK’S FEED CITY SLICKER FLOYD FANCY GERMAN CAR CITY SLICKER FLOYD CHUCK’S SEED CHUCK SUCK PARK AVENUE MANICURE GUCCI LOAFERS I CAN’T FEED GUCCI LOAFERS SUCK SEETHE
FOR FREE FOR FREE ON LEMMY SNEED ON LEMMY I CAN’T CLEAN IT UP JANNIES CHUCK’S DILATE COPE FANCY GERMAN CAR GUCCI LOAFERS CITY SLICKER COPE CITY SLICKER CITY SLICKER HOT POCKETS CHUCK’S GUCCI LOAFERS I CAN’T HOT POCKETS ON LEMMY FUCK SEED SUCK CLEAN IT UP I CAN’T FUCK CITY SLICKER FLOYD GUCCI LOAFERS SNEED’S FOR FREE FUCK DILATE ON LEMMY CHUCK CLEAN IT UP FEED CHUCK’S FEED CHUCK’S I CAN’T SNEED’S COPE I CAN’T FANCY GERMAN CAR FOR FREE PARK AVENUE MANICURE
AND FUCK SUCK ON LEMMY HOT POCKETS FANCY GERMAN CAR CITY SLICKER ON LEMMY FUCK FANCY GERMAN CAR SNEED’S JANNIES CHUCK FOR FREE CHUCK’S SEED SUCK AND CHUCK’S CLEAN IT UP CHUCK’S SEED HOT POCKETS SNEED’S ON LEMMY I CAN’T AND JANNIES CLEAN IT UP SEETHE SEETHE FEED SNEED FEED ON LEMMY FEED FANCY GERMAN CAR JANNY AND SNEED’S I CAN’T HOT POCKETS FLOYD PARK AVENUE MANICURE SUCK COPE CLEAN IT UP HOT POCKETS CHUCK’S AND
SNEED FLOYD CITY SLICKER SNEED JANNY CHUCK’S PARK AVENUE MANICURE JANNY PARK AVENUE MANICURE FOR FREE JANNIES JANNIES HOT POCKETS PARK AVENUE MANICURE COPE CITY SLICKER SNEED’S I CAN’T FANCY GERMAN CAR FANCY GERMAN CAR SNEED’S GUCCI LOAFERS SEETHE GUCCI LOAFERS JANNY COPE HOT POCKETS SNEED SNEED’S FOR FREE SUCK HOT POCKETS SNEED’S CHUCK ON LEMMY SEED CHUCK PARK AVENUE MANICURE CITY SLICKER JANNY DILATE SNEED FLOYD COPE JANNY FANCY GERMAN CAR HOT POCKETS SEETHE FANCY GERMAN CAR SEETHE
HOT POCKETS SUCK JANNY SUCK SEED CLEAN IT UP SEED SEED FUCK SNEED SNEED’S FOR FREE HOT POCKETS DILATE FANCY GERMAN CAR SNEED SNEED ON LEMMY JANNY SEED FOR FREE JANNY SNEED’S GUCCI LOAFERS SEED FANCY GERMAN CAR FANCY GERMAN CAR GUCCI LOAFERS FLOYD FUCK AND CHUCK’S SUCK PARK AVENUE MANICURE PARK AVENUE MANICURE JANNIES DILATE JANNY FOR FREE SUCK ON LEMMY FANCY GERMAN CAR PARK AVENUE MANICURE ON LEMMY COPE FLOYD SNEED’S FANCY GERMAN CAR CHUCK’S CHUCK’S
FOR FREE ON LEMMY CHUCK SNEED CHUCK’S SUCK HOT POCKETS SNEED FEED SNEED SNEED’S FEED FANCY GERMAN CAR DILATE FANCY GERMAN CAR SEED CHUCK’S AND CLEAN IT UP CLEAN IT UP SNEED’S CHUCK FUCK FEED PARK AVENUE MANICURE FEED ON LEMMY CITY SLICKER AND JANNY CLEAN IT UP CHUCK COPE HOT POCKETS CHUCK’S FLOYD SNEED CHUCK FEED FEED FANCY GERMAN CAR FLOYD HOT POCKETS I CAN’T AND HOT POCKETS ON LEMMY FLOYD SUCK SNEED’S
JANNY SEED AND CHUCK CHUCK SNEED ON LEMMY CHUCK’S FANCY GERMAN CAR SUCK SEETHE PARK AVENUE MANICURE AND SNEED PARK AVENUE MANICURE CHUCK ON LEMMY HOT POCKETS SNEED’S FUCK FUCK FLOYD JANNIES JANNY CLEAN IT UP FEED PARK AVENUE MANICURE FANCY GERMAN CAR JANNIES FOR FREE FLOYD SNEED’S CHUCK’S PARK AVENUE MANICURE CHUCK DILATE SEED CLEAN IT UP SEED AND GUCCI LOAFERS FLOYD GUCCI LOAFERS PARK AVENUE MANICURE FOR FREE SEETHE PARK AVENUE MANICURE HOT POCKETS PARK AVENUE MANICURE SNEED
FOR FREE SEED CHUCK’S CHUCK DILATE SEETHE I CAN’T HOT POCKETS FLOYD ON LEMMY FEED CITY SLICKER SNEED’S JANNY FLOYD DILATE JANNIES HOT POCKETS CITY SLICKER FOR FREE AND DILATE SNEED HOT POCKETS COPE CHUCK’S ON LEMMY DILATE FANCY GERMAN CAR DILATE CLEAN IT UP I CAN’T CITY SLICKER SNEED’S ON LEMMY I CAN’T PARK AVENUE MANICURE CITY SLICKER FOR FREE CITY SLICKER SNEED’S HOT POCKETS FUCK ON LEMMY SEETHE FANCY GERMAN CAR GUCCI LOAFERS I CAN’T ON LEMMY COPE
FEED JANNIES DILATE JANNIES FEED GUCCI LOAFERS FANCY GERMAN CAR FEED CHUCK’S SNEED’S JANNY FANCY GERMAN CAR FUCK DILATE SEETHE SEED FEED FOR FREE FUCK GUCCI LOAFERS CHUCK SUCK FUCK I CAN’T GUCCI LOAFERS CHUCK COPE COPE HOT POCKETS GUCCI LOAFERS FUCK GUCCI LOAFERS SUCK ON LEMMY ON LEMMY FUCK PARK AVENUE MANICURE HOT POCKETS SEETHE FEED HOT POCKETS FEED FOR FREE I CAN’T SNEED’S CLEAN IT UP FOR FREE FUCK HOT POCKETS SEETHE
FLOYD JANNY GUCCI LOAFERS AND CLEAN IT UP GUCCI LOAFERS SEED SUCK COPE SEETHE SNEED’S GUCCI LOAFERS FANCY GERMAN CAR SEETHE SEED DILATE FLOYD FLOYD FANCY GERMAN CAR JANNIES ON LEMMY ON LEMMY GUCCI LOAFERS FEED SNEED FEED SNEED’S FOR FREE DILATE FANCY GERMAN CAR AND SNEED CHUCK JANNIES FOR FREE SUCK SUCK FANCY GERMAN CAR FANCY GERMAN CAR ON LEMMY SUCK SUCK SEETHE ON LEMMY SUCK FOR FREE JANNIES PARK AVENUE MANICURE FOR FREE ON LEMMY
HOT POCKETS SEED CHUCK’S FOR FREE CHUCK’S SEETHE FANCY GERMAN CAR CITY SLICKER HOT POCKETS ON LEMMY PARK AVENUE MANICURE FEED COPE CLEAN IT UP FEED SNEED FANCY GERMAN CAR JANNY JANNY FEED I CAN’T SEED CITY SLICKER PARK AVENUE MANICURE SEETHE FOR FREE CHUCK ON LEMMY SEETHE HOT POCKETS SNEED CHUCK I CAN’T JANNY FUCK FANCY GERMAN CAR FEED FOR FREE FOR FREE CITY SLICKER FLOYD SNEED’S I CAN’T FUCK CHUCK’S SEED SNEED’S JANNIES FLOYD SNEED’S
COPE CITY SLICKER SUCK PARK AVENUE MANICURE CLEAN IT UP JANNY FUCK I CAN’T CITY SLICKER CLEAN IT UP ON LEMMY CHUCK ON LEMMY CITY SLICKER FEED FEED ON LEMMY AND CHUCK’S SNEED FANCY GERMAN CAR FEED SNEED SNEED’S SEED FLOYD SEETHE FOR FREE SEED DILATE SUCK HOT POCKETS HOT POCKETS CLEAN IT UP SUCK ON LEMMY ON LEMMY DILATE CLEAN IT UP FANCY GERMAN CAR FUCK SEED I CAN’T SNEED’S CHUCK’S SEETHE SNEED FUCK SNEED’S PARK AVENUE MANICURE
